Jan 3, 2025

Lexington Candy Shop New York

Period 1925 Luncheonette

"A timeless spot on Lexington Avenue, this 1948 luncheonette offers classic dishes, soda fountain treats, and vintage charm —unchanged since its heyday."

The ascension to recently lost ubiquity of NYC luncheonettes and soda fountains began in the 1920s when places like  S&P Luncheonette (on Broadway opposite the Flatiron building at Madison Square), the Lexington Candy Shop (Lexington Avenue at 83rd Street) and Eddie's Sweet Shop in Forest Hills originally opened.

This Lexington Avenue luncheonette —an uncommon survivor of many on that avenue—has altered nearly nothing since its most recent renovation in 1948. Even nearby Orwasher's Bakery—where bread is still made by hand and without preservatives—still provides the sandwich and French Toast ingredients.

As places to eat breakfast and lunch such luncheonettes face intrepid competition from restaurants offering menus based on more modern thinking, but for classic menu items and simply, the experience, there is no alternative.

Here, the white smocked soda jerks still utilize syrups and seltzer to fabricate all their soda fountain creations such as Chocolate Egg Creams, Malteds, Ice Cream Sodas, Frosted Floats, Orange Freezes, Creamsicle Freezes and Floats.

Or, for a first experience, coffee and pie á la mode might be the way to go.

The restaurant has—as one would expect— vinyl booths and a long formica counter with backless spinning stools, and in the Lexington avenue window, a collection of vintage glass Coca-cola bottles, above which hang original storefront neon signs which themselves may be landmarked.

This place is so original the phone number is still listed as BUtterfield 8-0057, the same exchange as for the John O'hara novel, Butterfield 8 and movie, starring Elizabeth Taylor.

020-coffee-cup-1
Coffee & tea
021-spoon-and-fork-1
Restaurants
024-burger-1
Snacks

About this spot

1226 Lexington Avenue, New York, NY, 10028,

Pie and Coffee:

US$

15

find your way in New York, download our app.

Find your way with 308 Insider Tips from our Local Spotters

Discover hidden gems and all our locals’ favourites! Get full access to our New York guide.

Nice place right!? There’s so much more to discover:

Discover all other hidden gems in New York

Don Alejo Coffee

Coffee, toasts and burritos

Their prices are in keeping with the neighborhood: a plate of two eggs, two pancakes, 'home' fried potatoes and your choice of sausages or bacon, is $12.

020-coffee-cup-1
Coffee & tea
024-burger-1
Snacks

by

Geoffrey

Dunbar

Sep 16, 2025

Icons' Homes

James, James & Dorothy

There are three houses not far from each other in NYC of three icons: James Dean, James Baldwin, and Dorothy Parker...

002-building
Art & culture

by

Geoffrey

Dunbar

Sep 16, 2025

Heckscher Field/Central Park

Broadway show league

"Heckscher Field" in Central Park, New York, is used for softball. Here you can see games played for the Broadway Show League. Celebrity stars may be seen.

002-building
Art & culture

by

Geoffrey

Dunbar

Sep 16, 2025

Verdi Square

People Watching

This sun soaked park bench is a destination neighborhood residents know, spending time there in observation. It’s one of the more fabulous NYC stages.

017-plant-1
Relaxing

by

Geoffrey

Dunbar

Sep 15, 2025

74St Café

American overlooking Beacon Theater

Among its offerings are a $10 breakfast special and its enormous $15 lunchtime hamburger, a price unobtainable anywhere else within walking distance.

021-spoon-and-fork-1
Restaurants

by

Geoffrey

Dunbar

Sep 15, 2025

Monumental Women

Central Park Monument Representing Real Women

"Monumental Women" has erected this monument in Central Park, NYC to especially important figures in the United States women's equality movement...

002-building
Art & culture

by

Geoffrey

Dunbar

Sep 13, 2025

Der Krung

Best Thai spot in town

"Der Krung" in Hell's Kitchen in New York City is by far my favorite Thai place around. One of the best things about it is the $9.75 lunch special...

021-spoon-and-fork-1
Restaurants

by

Christian

Neely

Sep 13, 2025

Apthorp Cleaners

Barbies, Barbies, Barbies

"Apthorp Cleaners" in NYC is different from the dozens of other neighborhood cleaners by its permanent but ever-changing window display of Barbie dolls...

002-building
Art & culture

by

Geoffrey

Dunbar

Sep 12, 2025

Taco Mix

Gorditas, Cemitas, Burrito Bowls

Taco toppings include cheese (Cotijam, oaxaca and mozzarella), pineapple, jalapeños and pico de gallo. Norteñas & Cubanos sandwiches are not to be missed.

021-spoon-and-fork-1
Restaurants

by

Geoffrey

Dunbar

Sep 11, 2025

Dinastia

Cuban - Chinese

"Dinastia" is a great Cuban-Chinese restaurant in New York City. They definitely make soul food here. Consider the squid and rice: it's always good...

002-building
Art & culture
021-spoon-and-fork-1
Restaurants

by

Geoffrey

Dunbar

Sep 11, 2025

Studio Museum in Harlem

Artists of color

"Studio Museum in Harlem" in New York focuses on local, national and international artists of African descent and other work inspired by black culture...

002-building
Art & culture

by

Geoffrey

Dunbar

Sep 11, 2025

Stand Up NY

UWS Comedy Club

Its bright neon sign is easy to spot. Stand Up NY feels like a proper theater as it has a street-level entrance and the programming is mad extensive,

019-lemonade-1
Theaters

by

Geoffrey

Dunbar

Sep 9, 2025

Heading to New York?

308 Insider Tips from our local Spotters

Authentic Stories by Real People

Escape the Crowd & Travel Slow 🐌

... for just €9.99

0 Insider Tips from our local Spotters

308 Insider Tips

✓ Escape the Crowds

✓ Find Spots nearby

✓ Authentic Stories

... for just €9.99

City guides by those who know the city in and out!

Our Locals' Favorite Coffee & tea

Our team loves New York

Get to know our other Spotters from New York

As featured on:

New-York-Times
the-guardian
mashable
the-sunday-times
[paywall_activator]
false
0
false
63
Made with the 💚 of 496 Spotters.
Filters