Goodfella's Pizza New York
My favorite Staten Island slice
It is the eternal debate: who serves the best pizza in New York City? Pizzerias across the five boroughs compete for the title. To me, there is no competition: Goodfella's pizzeria serves the best pies in New York City, and they have the awards to prove it! They are the proud winners of "World's Best Pizza" at the International Pizza Expo, and America’s Best Pizza for their Pizza Alla Vodka. But I think the truest testament to their success is all the many delicious dinners I have shared here with my family!
So what makes Goodfella's so great? They say their secret is high quality ingredients and their wood-fired brick oven. What I love is their inventive ingredients on their specialty pies. My favorite is their award-winning "Pizza Alla Vodka," which is topped with homemade vodka sauce, fresh mozzarella, prosciutto, mushrooms, and peas. It cleverly uses all the classic ingredients of a penne alla vodka dish, but served on a pizza! When I'm having dinner here with my family, we usually split a large pie. If we can't agree on a topping, we can get half Pizza Alla Vodka, and half topped with the Smokin' Goodfella, which is another of their award-winning pizzas.
Goodfella's has two pizzerias on Staten Island. Their original location is on Hylan Boulevard, where you'll see their trophies proudly displayed, as well as photos of famous patrons adorning the walls. New York Mayors Bill Di Blasio, Mike Bloomberg, and Rudy Giulliani are all fans!
About this spot
Find your way with 301 Insider Tips from our Local Spotters
Nice place right!? There’s so much more to discover:
Discover all other hidden gems in New York
Patsy's 'El Barrio'
Historic Pizzeria
Patsy’s, famed for its 900°F coal-fired pizza, still thrives in Spanish Harlem, gritty, iconic, and sublime. Thin crust, no tables, just pure NY history.
By
Geoffrey
Dunbar
The Old Print Shop
Flatiron District Gallery
"The Old Print Shop" in New York is my hands-down, hands-on museum/gallery of choice. I love mid-twentieth century 'industrial' or 'city' art...
By
Geoffrey
Dunbar
Sea & Sea
Fried fish takeout
"Sea & Sea " in NYC is a traditional-looking fish shop with wet, tiled floors, cool air, grated ice on every hand, busy with customers from near and far...
By
Geoffrey
Dunbar
Pikine
Senegalese restaurant
Come to "Pikine" in NYC to eat shoulder-to-shoulder with Senegalese people!
By
Geoffrey
Dunbar
Modern Bread and Bagel
Extreme gluten-free bagels
"Modern Bread and Bagel" in NYC has surfaced as exemplary, using criteria such as size and texture, seed and salt density. Here are some more top picks...
By
Geoffrey
Dunbar
The Dublin House
Irish Bar Centenarian
"The Dublin House" in NYC has been around since Prohibition and it still is neighborhood-sized. By the end of the night, everyone speaks Irish here...
By
Geoffrey
Dunbar
Pain d’ Epices
French / American patisserie
"Pain d' Epices" is a French bakery in NYC that makes croissants so flaky & buttery, the only way to avoid the crumbs is to 'put your back to the wind...'
By
Geoffrey
Dunbar
Django
Tribeca jazz boîte
"Django" in NYC is proof that the city's jazz club world is recovering. I celler/cavern is intimate enough that after performances I walk over to engage...
By
Geoffrey
Dunbar
Pastrami Queen
Traditional kosher Jewish deli
"Pastrami Queen" in NYC has if not the best, among the very best pastrami sandwiches in the city. It's the kind of American excess you just can't miss...
By
Geoffrey
Dunbar
Grandma's Place
Inclusive Books and Toys
I stumbled across a store about which I had read but never visited—the very inviting and colourful playground of Dawn Harris-Martine), retired teacher, now famous—named Grandma’s Place.
By
Geoffrey
Dunbar
Sisters Uptown Bookstore
African diaspora hub
"Sisters Uptown Bookstore" in NYC is a hidden shop/cultural center w/ an eye-opening trove of books by African diaspora authors. A true neighborhood spot!
By
Geoffrey
Dunbar
Color World
Curb Side BBQ
Color World sets up on the corner of 116th and 2nd Avenue, rain or shine. There they serve beef, pork, goat, oxtail, and chicken for $10 a plate.
By
Geoffrey
Dunbar
Heading to New York?
301 Insider Tips from our local Spotters
Authentic Stories by Real People
Escape the Crowd & Travel Slow 🐌
... for just €9.99
Heading to New York?
✓ 0 Insider Tips from our local Spotters
✓ 301 Insider Tips
✓ Escape the Crowds
✓ Find Spots nearby
✓ Authentic Stories
... for just €9.99
Our team loves New York
Get to know our other Spotters from New York
As featured on:
