Carole's Cheesecake Cafe Toronto
A treat for the ages!
Mauricio from Toronto
Did you know, that an ancient Greek physician name Aegimus, wrote a book on the art of making cheesecakes? (πλακουντοποιικόν σύγγραμμα—plakountopoiikon suggramma) True story! Wrote it around 5 BC! Although the exact preparation of cheesecakes has changed throughout the ages, the fact is we can honestly call this sweet treat a true classic.
As locals, we realise some restaurants or cafes are known for some things and not for others. Hence I will say this, Carole's does cheesecakes very well, with a solid selection albeit a finicky website. So, let's keep it to desserts.
Granted, finding this spot can be a bit tricky to first timers as it is located below street level but it should be easier if you keep an eye out for it. Come with a friend, a small group of friends (>4) or a date, perhaps at the beginning of your adventure or at the end of the night as you look for a place to wind down with a dessert.
Which cheesecake you ask? Well, that is quite the mission if you choose to accept it, as there are always plenty of choices. The night I was there they had 18 cakes to choose from, however... with many being rotated weekly as new flavours are brought in. From lime, cherry, tiramisu, strawberry, chocolate, Philly style, rocky road, walnut, to triple chocolate for you coco-junkies out there, there should always be something to match everyone's tastes.
FYI: Website is up again, however some links did not quite work.
Toronto Spotter Mauricio
About this spot
Our Toronto City Guide
Find your way with 145 Insider Tips from our Local Spotters
Loved it? Join us!
Loved this Spot?Join your international community. Share your favs and become part of our international community!
Nice place right!? There’s so much more to discover:
Discover all other hidden gems in Toronto
La Salumeria
The perfect midtown deli
"La Salumeria" is always where I go when I need something delicious on-the-go during the day. It's a delicatessen that also makes the best sandwiches!
by
Anita
Kim
Aloette
Toronto’s best restaurant's cooler sister
"Aloette" in Toronto is an upscale bistro with a wider range of food. Their burger is definitely a staple, and their iceberg wedge salad is a sleeper hit!
by
Anita
Kim
Gift Shop
A not-so-secret secret speakeasy
"Gift Shop" is a secret, magical, speakeasy-type cocktail bar at the back of a barber shop in Toronto. It's actually quite well known though, so get read
by
Anita
Kim
Swatow
My go-to for hole-in-the-wall Chinese food
"Swatow" Toronto's been my go-to for that kind of Chinese food for years -- you know, the comforting, inexpensive stuff that's still plentiful & delicious.
by
Anita
Kim
Parallel
My fave Israeli spot for brunch
"Parallel" in Toronto makes their own tahini with a huge stone grinder and they use it in just about every dish in the menu, including the amazing hummus.
by
Anita
Kim
The One in the Only
Coffee coffee coffee
"The One in the Only" in Toronto is an eclectic coffee shop that just exudes positivity. Most of the decoration is a random mix of old photos & art prints.
by
Jeffrey
Wood
The Only Cafe
Beer beer beer
"The Only Cafe" offers one of the widest selections of domestic and international beer in Toronto. After 30 years in business, it's quite iconic...
by
Jeffrey
Wood
Spacing Store
Real Toronto souvenirs
"Spacing Store" is the perfect place to pick up truly authentic Toronto souvenirs. Though I really think that it's more geared towards local fans...
by
Kasia
Kmiec
Envelōp
Toronto fashion designer
"Envelōp" in Toronto is a small independent store who designs smart men's and women's shirts right here in the city! Jim Smith is a true artisan...
by
Jeffrey
Wood
Lahore Tikka House
North Indian cuisine
"Lahore Tikka House" is my favorite North Indian and Pakistani restaurant in this part of Toronto. Definitely try the tikkas & Lahori Kulfi ice cream.
by
Jeffrey
Wood
The Real Jerk Restaurant
Caribbean bar & eatery
"The Real Jerk Restaurant" in Toronto has been a Caribbean and Jamaican mainstay since 1984. Try their namesake cocktail and the curried goat and rice...
by
Jeffrey
Wood
Gooderham Building
Toronto's own Flat-Iron
"Gooderham Building" is Toronto's very own Flat-Iron, only built earlier than the one in New York, in the early 1890s. I really like it for many...
by
Kasia
Kmiec
Heading to Toronto?
145 Insider Tips from our local Spotters
Authentic Stories by Real People
Escape the Crowd & Travel Slow 🐌
... for just €9.99
Heading to Toronto?
✓ 0 Insider Tips from our local Spotters
✓ 145 Insider Tips
✓ Escape the Crowds
✓ Find Spots nearby
✓ Authentic Stories
... for just €9.99
City guides by those who know the city in and out!
Our Locals' Favorite Coffee & tea
Our team loves Toronto
Get to know our other Spotters from Toronto
As featured on:
