Chicago Pizza and Oven Grinder Chicago

My go-to Italian

Sydney from Chicago

""Chicago Pizza and Oven Grinder" ranks as my top contender for a unique spin on hearty, warming, homemade Italian fare in the city... I love it in winter!"

Chicago Pizza & Oven Grinder is truly a Chicago gem – a quaint, cozy spot famed by locals for its unique take on homemade Italian fare. Judging by the crowd of hungry visitors waiting on the steps outside the restaurant’s doors, you would never guess that this restaurant is considered somewhat of a hidden spot to natives; however, compared to its swanky, more popular competitors, CPOG ranks as my top contender for a unique spin on hearty, warming, homemade Italian fare in the city.

My favorite time to visit CPOG is in the dead of winter, when I can retreat to the dimly lit Swedish-pub style hideaway and snuggle into a warm booth to enjoy a meal. I suggest only going with one other person, allowing you to partake in what I’ve deemed “the classic split” – splitting a half-size of the house salad, one Mediterranean bread (regular or whole wheat) and one pot pie. Accompanied by a flight of dressings – all of which are made in-house - the salad pairs perfectly with the incredibly-seasoned flatbread.

While I visit time and time again for their salad and flatbread combo, that’s not to say that their unique take on the classic pizza falls short of perfection. Servers cover the spud with a ceramic bowl as it's transported directly from oven to table. Upon arrival, the bowl is lifted and the fragrant smells of cheese, fresh tomato, garlic & a blend of seasonings pull forks and knives, if by will, to dig into delicious paradise.

Bars

Restaurants

This week 25% off

with the code fall25

*on our yearly membership

Chicago Spotter Sydney

About me I am a Chicago native best defined for my curiosity and willingness to explore. I value uniqueness and quality, which attributes to my appreciation for the city and for the entertainment it provides. With a close-knit set of friends and family nearby, I am often exploring the areas around me with peers by my side. Whether it’s through travel or leisure activities, I am always looking for the next opportunity to discover my surroundings and enjoy the entertainment and livelihood I find. Why Chicago? Having lived in Chicago my entire life, I am a p...

About this spot

North Clark Street 2121

1/2lb pizza pie:

USD

14.75

Website

7732482570

Social

Oct 2, 2025

Our Chicago City Guide

Find your way with 116 Insider Tips from our Local Spotters

Discover hidden gems and all our locals’ favourites! Get full access to our Chicago guide.

Loved it? Join us!

Loved this Spot?Join your international community. Share your favs and become part of our international community!

Nice place right!? There’s so much more to discover:

Discover all other hidden gems in Chicago

Luft Balloons

Decorating Chicago with balloons

Luft Balloons in Chicago isn't just a balloon shop – it's a female-operated & owned business that makes balloon sculptures specifically for marches...

Shopping

Sophie

Amado

Nov 24, 2025

Lincoln Tap Room

Dive with great drink specials

Lincoln Tap Room offers unmatched drink specials, retro vibes, and Steelers pride in a cozy, no-frills space on lively Lincoln Avenue.

Bars

Sophie

Amado

Nov 21, 2025

The Catcade

Cat cafe+arcade

The arcade-themed Catcade in Chicago's Lakeview neighborhood has been a crucial stop for all cat lovers since 2017 — play games, cuddle cats, adopt!

Coffee & tea

Relaxing

Sophie

Amado

Nov 21, 2025

La Creperie

Chicago's staple French restaurant

I've been going to La Creperie on Clark since I was a kid and it has never disappointed me — don’t miss the dreamy back patio and cozy French classics.

Restaurants

Sophie

Amado

Nov 20, 2025

TARY Coffee House

Kazakh specialty cafe

There are many unique food options to try on their menu like Bylamyk porridge with raspberry jam, Baursak (fried dough bites) or Truffle Mushroom Soup.

Coffee & tea