Magic John's Berlin

NY-style Pizza in Berlin

Natalie from Berlin

"A classic slice of pepperoni or truffle mushroom is the way to go here, although they offer other great toppings like olive, ricotta, salsiccia, and even vegan butternut squash."

For some of the tastiest NY-style pizza east of the Atlantic, visit Magic John's. They are a cult favorite in Berlin, and with good reason! Their pizza by the slice is the perfect pick-me-up if you're strolling around this pretty area of Mitte. They originally started out with just NY slices, but they now also offer Detroit deep dish. Both styles of pizza are certainly a rarity for the area, which makes it such an intriguing spot for so many Berliners.

A classic slice of pepperoni or truffle mushroom is the way to go here, although they offer other great toppings like olive, ricotta, salsiccia, and even vegan butternut squash. Their newest addition features a creamy and spicy vodka sauce topped with mozzarella, jalapeño, and caramelized cheddar. I have yet to try it, but I will report back, as it sounds heavenly.

Give them a try and be amazed. They're great at what they do. Plus, you can start your pizza meal with a round of garlic or miso cheddar knots, or end it with a slice of key lime coconut smash. Delicious!

Snacks

Buy one, Give one!

Share your 💚 this December

*on all products

Berlin Spotter Natalie

About me I’m Natalie, a Berlin-based blogger from California, USA. After studying abroad in Berlin nearly ten years ago, I knew there was so much more in the city to discover so I decided to move to Berlin several years later. I'm a copywriter and editor who works from home, so I try to get out and explore the city as much as possible because of my flexible schedule. On my blog, natalieetc.com, I write about my favorite places in Berlin, food, local tips, personal inspiration, and my travels outside of the city. My favorite thing to write about is food! I visit a diverse mix of restauran...

About this spot

Oranienburger Str. 48

Pizza slice:

€

Website

+49

03091570700

Social

Oct 11, 2025

Our Berlin City Guide

Find your way with 217 Insider Tips from our Local Spotters

Discover hidden gems and all our locals’ favourites! Get full access to our Berlin guide.

Loved it? Join us!

Loved this Spot?Join your international community. Share your favs and become part of our international community!

Nice place right!? There’s so much more to discover:

Discover all other hidden gems in Berlin

Idealpassage

A historic walk in Neukölln

"Idealpassage" in Berlin takes you on a historic walk - this passage reveals a complex from a century ago that served as a model for 'social housing'...

Art & culture

Anna

Hantelmann

Dec 6, 2025

Oxfam Schöneberg

International books for charity

"Oxfam Schöneberg" in Berlin deals in second-hand books! It offers a surprisingly interesting variety of international books...

"Mauerpark’s Books" in Berlin is perfect for old book lovers - and people who like bargaining for the best price!

Art & culture

"Antiquariat Wegner" in Berlin is an antiquarian bookstore that's just a paradise for German-speaking books. I admire it profoundly.

Art & culture

Relaxing

Shopping

Cheong Kin

Man

Dec 6, 2025

Tucholsky-Buchhandlung

In the name of the writer

"Tucholsky-Buchhandlung' in Berlin offers general literature for very reasonable prices. Clients coming to pick up their pre-ordered loves warms my heart!

Art & culture

Shopping

Cheong Kin

Man

Dec 6, 2025

Winterfeldt Schokoladen

Cafe in an old pharmacy

"Winterfeldt Schokoladen" in Berlin offers not only great coffee but also chocolates & some sweet treats! My choice is usually the shamanic chilli cacao...